The Quran did not spell out a punishment for the consumption of intoxicants either in private or in public. By making public consumption of alcohol an offence under the Syariah Criminal Offences Act, the government has criminalized what is deemed a personal sin.
Quran tidak menjelaskan darihal hukuman ke atas peminum arak samada dalam majlis tertutup ataupun terbuka. Dengan meletakkan perbuatan meminum arak di khalayak sebagai satu kesalahan di bawah Akta Kesalahan Jenayah Syariah kerajaan sebenarnya telah meletakkan sebagai jenayah satu yang sebenarnya sekadar kesalahan (dosa) peribadi.
Sumber hukum di dalam Islam adalah berpandukan al Quran, Hadis, Qias dan Ijmak. Memahami hukum dan perundangan Islam menuntut penguasaan terhadap kempat-empat sumber ini, itullah disiplinnya.Apabila Masjaliza berhujah yang Quran tidak menjelaskan darihal hukuman yang sepatutnya dikenakan terhadap peminum arak, beliau seolah-olah menolak sumber hukum Islam yang lain. Disinilah bukti kurangnya penguasaan ilmu Masjaliza sedangkan beliau mewakili NGO yang acapkali mahu sahaja mengeluarkan ulasan berkenaan Islam.
SIS juga begitu lantang tidak bersetuju dengan hukum-hukum terutama yang bersangkutan dengan hukum kekeluargaan Islam.
Kita renungi pula tulisan Dr Yusuf Qardawi yang berbunyi:
Sesungguhnya ilmu pengetahuan mesti didahulukan atas amal perbuatan, karena ilmu pengetahuanlah yang mampu membedakan antara yang haq dan yang bathil dalam keyakinan umat manusia, antara yang benar dan yang salah di dalam perkataan mereka, antara perbuatan-perbuatan yang disunatkan dan yang bid ah dalam ibadah, antara yang benar dan yang tidak benar di dalam melakukan muamalah, antara tindakan yang halal dan tindakan yang haram, antara yang terpuji dan yang hina di dalam akhlak manusia; antara ukuran yang diterima dan ukuran yang ditolak; antara perbuatan dan perkataan yang bisa diterima dan yang tidak dapat diterima.
Malahan penubuhan apa yang dikatakan IFC itu pun menerima sokongan dan galakkan kuat dari SIS.
Nori Abdullah adalah seorang aktivis SIS. Beliau sering mengikuti program, anjuran SIS. Kalau benar SIS mengancam kestabilan Islam maka Menteri Keselamatan Dalam Negeri perlu menjalankan penyiasatan.
Sebagai bukti kuatnya hubungan antara Nori dan SIS terutama terajunya Zainah Anwar berikut saya perturunkan sedutan dari sebuah artikel yang terbit dalam THE NEW YORK TIMES pada 19 Febuari 2006 lalu:
A model progressive Muslim country, Ms. Zainah observed, cannot show the world that it makes laws that discriminate against women and that allows its religious authorities to snatch away the body of a dead man from his grieving Hindu family.As Ms. Zainah, a graduate of the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy at Tufts University, goes into battle, she holds some formidable cards. Chief among them are candor, not caring what others think and a refusal to be intimidated. She has not married, and said, I dont want to be a slave to a man.Another advantage: Ms. Zainah is close to two progressive women with powerful connections, Marina Mahathir, the daughter of the former prime minister, and Nori Abdullah, the daughter of the current prime minister. He gets an earful from her, Ms. Zainah said, referring to Mr. Abdullah and his daughter.
Zainah dilaporkan menyebut bahawa Abdullah (Perdana Menteri) akan mendengar cakap Nori dan Zainah mempunyai hubungan rapat dengan Nori!
Kini dalam soal usul yang dibawa oleh PAS dalam muktamar ke 55 baru-baru ini, SIS telah melancarkan petition online..
Malaysiakini - Two ex-PM daughters join SIS online petition.
Thursday, 11 June 2009
By Emily Chow
Two daughters of former prime ministers have joined hundreds of Malaysians in an online petition to support of Sisters In Islam (SIS) in the wake of a PAS’ call for the women’s organisation to be banned. Nori Abdullah (right in photo), daughter of former PM Abdullah Ahmad Badawi and Marina Mahathir, daughter of another former PM, Dr Mahathir Mohamad, have both signed the petition.
The Star - Shahrizat defends Sisters in Islam
KUALA LUMPUR: Datuk Seri Shahrizat Abdul Jalil has come to the defence of Sisters In Islam (SIS), which PAS wants banned if its activities were against the religion, saying the Islamist party should learn to accept differing views.
The Women, Family and Community Development Minister said if PAS could not even accommodate the differing views of some Muslim women activists, “how can they tolerate the dissenting non-Muslim voices?”
Although the ministry did not always see eye-to-eye with any non-governmental organisations or individuals on certain matters, it had never called for any punishment against them, she said in a press statement Monday.
New Straits times - Dr M defends Sisters in Islam from Pas assault
By : Joseph Sipalan
KUALA LUMPUR : Former premier Tun Dr Mahathir Mohammad took a swipe at Pas today for proposing a ban on Sisters in Islam (SIS). Making his case against the party in a short blog posting, Dr Mahathir said he was “saddened” by the proposal, one of 11 resolutions passed by Pas at its recent Muktamar last week.
“I don’t always agree with the views of the SIS, but they have not negated Islam.
“In most instances they cite verses of the Quran and Hadith to support their views. If we don’t agree then give the reasons why we don’t agree ... to resort to banning is draconian,” he said on his blog, chedet.cc.
No comments:
Post a Comment